top of page

5 Psychological Battles of Writing a Resume

  • Ronald Replan
  • Jul 13, 2025
  • 3 min read

Typical resume tips often oversimplify the process. They suggest it's straightforward: just list your job history, add your education, make it readable, and you're set. 

 

But anyone who's tried writing their own resume knows it's not that simple.

It's not just a basic writing exercise; it's a multifaceted challenge that tests various aspects of your brain. More than recounting your work history, wordsmithing, editing, and translating everything into Business English, resume writing is also a deep, personal journey into who you are and what you have achieved.

 

As a professional resume writer, I've seen firsthand that crafting a resume is a unique challenge. In my sessions with clients, I've encountered moments of revelation, regret, and intense self-criticism:


“I honestly don’t know what job I want.”

"Wow, I did that? I am actually not a loser."

"I still like that role… even after they fired me."


These moments reveal the crucial truth that writing a resume isn’t just about writing skills, and understanding this challenge is key to effectively presenting the most complex subject you'll ever write about: you.

Now, let's explore the key challenges that make resume writing uniquely hard:


1. The High Stakes


A resume is arguably the most important document of your life. It's a ticket to a potential job that will pay the bills. And to opportunities that could define your daily life for years. No pressure, right?



2. Your Internalized Judgment


Delving into your resume is like walking through a gallery of your career choices, each bullet point a snapshot of memories. Remember quitting that one job after less than a year? What about that failed promotion? That toxic boss?

The idea of strangers evaluating your worth, based on your history on a few pages, is daunting. 

 

It can lead to second-guessing every line, potentially amplifying your insecurities.


3. Unclear Wants


One of the biggest hurdles in resume writing is the guessing game of what the recruiter wants to see. This uncertainty can escalate if you are unsure about the type of job you desire.

Imagine the anxiety of trying to hit a moving target – the multitude of things a hiring manager might be looking for in a candidate.



This uncertainty can lead to an explosion of 'what-ifs' and 'maybes,' often leading to an endless cycle of doubt and revision.


4. The Strangeness of Selling "You"


A well-written resume paints a vivid picture of who you are. You’re not just listing facts; you’re writing the story of 'you'. And this story has to impress.

However, unless you're a narcissist, hyping yourself up can feel awkward. Yet, that’s the game of resumes – a game that you can’t not play.

 

On the other hand, what if you play the game too well and not live up to the hype? This fear of overpromising can be paralyzing.


5. The Authenticity Challenge


A resume forces us to condense our multifaceted selves into a streamlined narrative. But people aren't simple. We’re not characters in a fairy tale with clear arcs; we’re complex and layered. Yet, for the sake of remembrance, we must be summarized into two pages.

And sometimes, to score an interview, we tweak the story further until we reach the point where we ask, “is this still me?”



In summary, writing a resume is hard — much harder than most acknowledge. It’s not just about capturing your professional life in bullet points; it's about capturing 'you' in a language that's not quite your own, for an audience you've never met, while still staying true to yourself.

 

Throughout this process, remember that the toughest critic you'll need to convince first is not the hiring manager – it’s you.

 

This is a journey of self-discovery requiring honesty and resilience. You'll need to confront and reconcile your self-doubts with your achievements, openly express your strengths, and come to terms with your imperfections.

 

So, manage your expectations. Recognize that resume writing isn't just another task – it's a significant project about you, for you. 

 

If you approach it this way, you won't only stand a chance in an increasingly competitive job market; you'll also gain something that truly sets you apart — self-confidence.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page